Mike Snead on Augustine Committee "Options and Decisions"

After reviewing the slides in the presentation “Options and Decisions on Human Exploration Discussion, August 5, 2009, my impression that the decision process ignores a needed focus on human space flight safety. How is it possible to prepare, review, debate, accept, and implement recommendations as to system architectures, operational capabilities, and specific system choices without first debating and establishing a human space flight safety framework that will enable the outcome of the panel’s deliberations to move U.S. human space travel substantially towards passenger-safe transportation? This represents an apparent fundamental flaw in the organization and execution of the panel in that it appears to lack appropriate representation of professional engineers experienced with assuring adequate passenger-safety in human transportation systems.

If the medical community were discussing the creation of a new medical policy to address a national healthcare need, fundamental to their deliberations would be creating recommendations consistent with professionally-approved healthcare protocols. Discussions of approaches that used non-medically-approved treatments, such as non FAA-unapproved drugs, would not be taken into the final phase of recommendation formulation unless such plans also called for the specific steps needed to first bring such treatments to approval status.

U.S. human space flight implementation has long ignored the responsibility to address the substantial weakness of current space transportation systems for passenger travel under the continued guise of “right stuff” astronauts. There was a time when such clear bravery was needed and greatly benefited the nation. However, all new transportation systems go through this phase and then, wisely, move on to implementing the improvements needed to increase safety from the “test-pilot” phase to that consistent with passenger travel. How can the U.S. move forward in its needed transformation into a true spacefaring nation–where Americans as spacefarers can routinely and safety travel to and from space–while ignoring a common sense regard for establishing reasonable passenger travel safety? Traveling to and from LEO is neither that vital nor that technically difficult with fully-reusable space access systems that passenger safety should be causally dismissed simply because this is the way it has been handled for 40 years.

The Human Space Flight Plans Committee needs to reassess requirements and solutions for achieving passenger-safe space travel and specifically factor this into its review, deliberations, and recommendations.

Mike Snead, P.E.
Spacefaring Institute LLC


Picture of admin


Contributors to the NSS Blog are unpaid volunteers. Unless specifically labeled an NSS position or press release, all blog posts represent the views of the author and not of NSS, even if written by an NSS officer.

Leave a Comment

future 1

Don't Miss a Beat!

Be the first to know when new articles are posted!

Follow Us On Social Media


Give The Gift Of Space: Membership For Friends and Family

Book Review


ISDC 2024:

International Space Development Conference May 23rd-26th, 2024


Image of Kalpana One space settlement courtesy Bryan Versteeg, spacehabs.com $32,000 in Cash Awards Given for Best Space-Related Business Plans — Deadline March 1, 2024

Category: Nonfiction Reviewed by: John J. Vester Title: Nuclear Rockets: To the Moon and Mars Author: Manfred “Dutch” von Ehrenfried Format: Paperback/Kindle Pages: 270 Publisher:

Partially Successful Flight Reached Space and Demonstrated New “Hot Staging” System The National Space Society congratulates SpaceX on the second test of its Starship/Super Heavy

Ad Astra, the NSS quarterly print, digital, and audio magazine, has won a 2023 MARCOM Gold Award. The awards are given yearly for “Excellence in

By Jennifer Muntz, NSS Member Coordinator On October 10th, an inspiring breakfast event took flight at the Center for Space Education at the Kennedy Space

By Grant Henriksen NSS Policy Committee Benefit sharing is a concept that refers to the distribution of benefits derived from the exploration and use of

People residing and working in space, space settlements, or on long-duration space flights will need to produce infrastructures and food to maintain healthy lifestyles. The

Image: Artist’s concept of the Blue Moon lander. Credit: Blue Origin. Second Human Landing System Contract Encourages Competition and Innovation The National Space Society congratulates