National Space Society

Share:

Facebook
X
Pinterest
LinkedIn

ISDC conference report by Dave Fischer

If those who think Mars is sufficiently hard to get to and remain to settle are correct, or those who think that it would be a terrible mistake to go to Mars and return leaving only flags and footprints are correct, then we are, in fact, not going to Mars anytime soon.  So where are we going?  And why are we going?

The current Flexible Path suggests that the manned exploration of an asteroid is a reasonable goal.  It avoids the problems of deep gravity wells, and does create launch vehicles and spacecraft.  However, as critics point out, this merely repeats the standard process of throwing away everything except the manned return capsule.  What might be done to create a permanent space faring infrastructure?

Why we are going is settlement.  That is the conclusion from reading policy statements, both formal and informal, from the past 10 years.  Beginning with the Vision for Space Exploration statement in 2004, up through the 2010 statement by the Obama administration, these policy statements all point toward the unspoken word, “settlement”.  Permanent occupation of space that exploits the economic resources available is the goal.  Now, what are the initial strategic steps, and what are the tactics to implement them.

At the International Space Development Conference (ISDC 2011), two proposals were made that result in permanent cislunar infrastructure: one by Dr. Paul Spudis and one by Stephen D. Covey.

Dr. Spudis advocated the conservative approach.  During Friday’s luncheon, Dr. Spudis presented “Can We Afford to Return to the Moon” (see the paper in the NSS Lunar Library by Spudis and Lavoie Mission and Implementation of an Affordable Lunar Return – pdf)

Spudis and Lavoie argue that over a period of roughly 16 years, employing a series of 31 missions, that a robotically built water mining operation at the South Pole of the moon, later employing humans living at the base to repair and maintain the equipment, would yield the following:

1.  Commercially valuable water for use as Lox/H2 fuel on the Moon and within cislunar space, sufficient to sustain the operation, with excess available for sale.

2.  Reusable Landers and Rovers.

3.  Permanent human occupation of the Moon.

4.  Routine access to all space assets within Cislunar space, including communications, GPS, weather, remote sensing and strategic monitoring satellites.

In essence, we create a “transcontinental railroad” with permanent settlements at various points between the Earth and the Moon.  The critical element is that this can be accomplished with the $7 Billion annual budget likely to be given NASA for the foreseeable future.  The projected cost of a Flexible Path mission to an asteroid has been estimated at $80 Billion, while the Cislunar project would cost $77 Billion.

The second proposal is far more radical: “Asteroid Capture for Space Solar Power”.  Here, Stephen D. Covey argued for a purely commercial venture to capture the asteroid 99942 Apophis, mine it for metals, silicon and oxygen, build Solar Power Satellites (SPS) and sell the power to utility companies on Earth.  An initial capital base of $30 Billion would be required.  But by the end of the sixth or seventh year of operation the enterprise would be at break even, and eventually generate $20 Billion per year in revenue.

At the end of eight years, 15 Solar Power Satellites would be in operation generating $20 Billion per year in revenue.  And only 10% of the asteroid would have been processed.  A total of 150 SPSs could be manufactured before another asteroid was needed.

The end result of this initial eight-year plan would be:

1.  A fully shielded (3 meters of slag from the mining operation) habitat for 8,000 people.

2.  Space based factory capable of producing 8 SPSs per year.

3.  Space infrastructure created by commercial space companies to support the operations.

4.  3-4% of Earth’s electrical needs supplied by Space based Solar Power

At the end of production, with 150 Satellites in operation, more than a third of Earth’s electrical needs would be supplied by Space Based Solar Power.

And who is to suggest that we cannot do both of these ventures at the same time?

Share:

Facebook
X
Pinterest
LinkedIn
Picture of By National Space Society

By National Space Society

1 thought on “Constructing Cislunar Infrastructure – ISDC 2011”

  1. Here’s a third path. Have NASA fund:
    – Commercial Lunar Cargo
    – Commercial Lunar Crew
    – Commercial Cis-lunar Supply.

    Use Falcon Heavies to cut down on the cost and number of missions as compared to Spudis’ Plan. As is being done with Dragon, have the lunar cargo landers be designed for manned rating but have them deliver teleported equipment first until they are proven save for humans. Then, send the humans to repair the teleported robots but also to extract metals to produce the bulky parts of more telerobots so as to greatly expand the provision of lunar ice-derived fuel throughout cis-lunar space.

    Producing life support from lunar ice (including methane and ammonia for fertilizer) and machining in situ metals and producing glass will get you a fair ways to the initial, largely self-supporting settlement.

    Reply

Leave a Comment

Don't Miss a Beat!

Be the first to know when new articles are posted!

Search
Categories

Follow Us On Social Media

JOIN THE
GREATEST ADVENTURE

Give The Gift Of Space: Membership For Friends and Family

Book Review

Lunacy

Lunacy: A Book Review Essay

This long essay defends the NSS Vision against those who, like the author of the book being reviewed, think “we shouldn’t colonize Mars or the Moon, or even vacation there.” Ben Bramble, an Australian philosopher who teaches at Australian National University, has penned a YAASS (Yet Another Anti-Space-Settlement) book. These books are multiplying like flies, so space settlement advocates must be gaining ground to generate such an abundant response.

Read More »
HOTOLSkylon

Book Review: HOTOL & Skylon: The Story of Britain’s Spaceplanes

In HOTOL & Skylon: The Story of Britain’s Spaceplanes, Rob Coppinger covers the story of both in great detail, with the reminiscences of many who played integral roles in these ambitious programs. The book shines when it captures the enthusiasm and excitement of those involved, and there are extensive quotes from many who devoted years of work on these projects.

Read More »
Out of This World

Book Review: Out of This World

Anyone seeking a short but comprehensive introduction to human spaceflight would do well to start with this book. It reviews its history, highlights the accomplishments and tragedies, and describes the equipment used. It also looks at living in space, what space travelers experience, and how they work.

Read More »
Archives


Hilton McLean Tysons Corner, McLean, Virginia
June 4 - 7, 2026

Recent Blog Posts

By Burt Dicht NSS Space Coast Correspondent Image: Artist’s concept of living and working at Moon Base, courtesy NASA “We are building the Moon Base...

NSS is pleased to share this inspiring story of how a 17-year-old from Venezuela discovers asteroids. By Miguel Rojas It was the kind of night...

Category: Nonfiction Reviewed by: Clifford R. McMurray Title: Eyes to the Stars: A Memoir for the Space Shuttle Generation Author: Steven A. Hawley, PhD Format:...

Isaacman and NASA Associate Administrator Amit Kshatriya outlined the changes NASA is making to accelerate the Artemis program. Artemis Program Manager Jeremy Parsons followed with...
While most meteorites come from asteroids, a small number originate from the Moon or Mars. Powerful impacts can eject surface rocks into space, where they...
The National Space Society is proud to host the annual Space Settlement Summit at the campus of the University of Central Florida on October 25...

By Burt Dicht NSS Space Coast Correspondent Image: After the first Young Professionals breakfast at the ISDC. Included is astronaut Susan Kilrain (center) and NSS...

It is with great sadness that we share the passing of Peter Kokh on October 4, 2026, at the age of 88. Peter was Lifetime...
adastra magazine

Your Doorway to New Worlds