catching stardust
The best account we have so far of pioneering missions to sample comets and asteroids: The NASA Stardust mission to sample a comet, the Japanese Hayabusa asteroid sample return mission, and the ESA Rosetta probe to land on a comet. The author is a geochemist who was involved in all three missions.

Category: Nonfiction
Reviewed by: Clifford R. McMurray
Title: Catching Stardust: Comets, Asteroids and the Birth of the Solar System
Author: Natalie Starkey
NSS Amazon link for this book
Format: Hardcover, Kindle
Pages: 256
Publisher: Bloomsbury Sigma
Date: June 2018
Retail Price: $27.00/$9.99
ISBN: 978-1472944009

Asteroids and comets are the keys to our past and our future. They are the last relatively pristine samples of the nebula of interstellar gas and dust from which our solar system was formed, they are full of the resources we’ll need to settle the solar system, and unless we learn how to deflect them when their orbits inevitably intersect with Earth, they’ll eventually become the instruments of our extinction, as they have already been for most of the species that have lived on Earth in the past.

Natalie Starkey is a geochemist who has analyzed samples collected by the NASA Stardust mission to a comet and the Japanese Space Agency (JAXA) Hayabusa sample return from asteroid Itokawa. She was a co-investigator for one of the instruments on European Space Agency (ESA) Rosetta probe, the first mission to land on a comet. In this book she shares her enthusiasm for the scientific investigation of these bodies, and what they tell us about our own origin.

Before we were able to send probes out to take close-up measurements of asteroids and comets, and even return samples for study on Earth, scientists had to work with the limited information they could get through telescopes and the bits of cosmic debris that survive passage through our atmosphere. The samples were heavily biased in favor of stones that could survive the heat of passage through Earth’s atmosphere at several miles per second. We knew that asteroids and comets contain water and organic chemicals—in fact, the Late Heavy Bombardment phase of solar system formation, in which many comets and asteroids were swept up by the planets, may have seeded Earth with water and the building blocks of life. But those parts of the meteors, still falling to Earth at the rate of about 100 tons per day, are vaporized before they get to the ground. Now, with probes and sample return missions such as those in which Starkey has participated, we get to see unaltered fossils of the first solidified bits of the solar nebula. The solar system is over four billion years old, but these bits date back to the first few tens of millions of years in our history.

Starkey first takes us through the story of the formation of the solar system as scientists understand it, and then shows how the space missions of the last few decades have changed what they thought they knew, and threw complications and questions into simple theories. The plot has thickened considerably. Objects thought to have formed in one part of the solar nebula may have formed somewhere else entirely before migrating to the places we find them today. That even goes for the biggest objects in the solar system, the gas giant planets, including Jupiter.

The missions Starkey describes show the adventure of science, as well as some of the unforeseen problems that can arise when doing things for the first time. The Hayabusa sample collection device didn’t trigger at the right time, so it captured a much smaller sample than scientists had hoped for. Yet the instruments that could be brought to bear on this tiny sample when it got back to Earth were so powerful that they could learn a lot. Likewise, the Philae lander on the Rosetta mission to Comet Churyumov-Gerasimenko hit its planned touchdown point perfectly, but the surface was unexpectedly hard, so it bounced back into space and landed at a shadowed location so its solar cells couldn’t recharge its batteries. Nevertheless, it managed to return some useful data.

This is an interesting book that could have been better in the hands of a better writer. Starkey’s prose is at times clumsy and annoyingly repetitive. She’s no Carl Sagan. The subject matter is sufficiently compelling to make this only a minor irritation, but it doesn’t stop me from noticing, and wishing for a more skilled narrator. For the time being, this book is the best account we have of some of these pioneering missions.

© 2018 Clifford R. McMurray

Please use the NSS Amazon Link for all your book and other purchases. It helps NSS and does not cost you a cent! Bookmark this link for ALL your Amazon shopping!

NSS Book Reviews Index


Picture of National Space Society

National Space Society

Leave a Comment

future 1

Don't Miss a Beat!

Be the first to know when new articles are posted!

Follow Us On Social Media


Give The Gift Of Space: Membership For Friends and Family

Book Review


ISDC 2025:
Together Beyond!

In Orlando at the Rosen Centre Hotel.
June 19 - 22, 2025


Image of Kalpana One space settlement courtesy Bryan Versteeg, $32,000 in Cash Awards Given for Best Space-Related Business Plans — Deadline March 1, 2024

Category: Nonfiction Reviewed by: John J. Vester Title: Nuclear Rockets: To the Moon and Mars Author: Manfred “Dutch” von Ehrenfried Format: Paperback/Kindle Pages: 270 Publisher:

Partially Successful Flight Reached Space and Demonstrated New “Hot Staging” System The National Space Society congratulates SpaceX on the second test of its Starship/Super Heavy

Ad Astra, the NSS quarterly print, digital, and audio magazine, has won a 2023 MARCOM Gold Award. The awards are given yearly for “Excellence in

By Jennifer Muntz, NSS Member Coordinator On October 10th, an inspiring breakfast event took flight at the Center for Space Education at the Kennedy Space

By Grant Henriksen NSS Policy Committee Benefit sharing is a concept that refers to the distribution of benefits derived from the exploration and use of

People residing and working in space, space settlements, or on long-duration space flights will need to produce infrastructures and food to maintain healthy lifestyles. The

Image: Artist’s concept of the Blue Moon lander. Credit: Blue Origin. Second Human Landing System Contract Encourages Competition and Innovation The National Space Society congratulates